infovore + criticism + innovation 2
Just What is Innovation Really Worth?
november 2008 by infovore
"The point in pointing out these numbers, since we’re throwing out analogies to films and videogame innovation, is that it seems that no matter how well a movie is interpreted as “innovative” by a reviewer, the truest mark of success lies in its ability to inure itself with the consumer." No. Commercial success is just one kind of success, and films like Eraserhead have had a far greater impact on young filmmakers than any amount of box-office smashes. The real rarities are films such as the Godfather or Citizen Kane, which manage to be box-office smashes and innovative masterpiece.
wrong
criticism
innovation
success
games
films
movies
reviews
november 2008 by infovore
Keith Stuart: Do game reviewers really understand innovation? | Technology | guardian.co.uk
november 2008 by infovore
"The 'better sequel' mentality is damaging both to the games industry and to the quality of games journalism. It is a deferral of critical responsibility, a patronising pat on the head for the developer who dared to dream and fell short in some mythically vital way. I don't want to be frustrated by dodgy controls either, but then I'm willing to blunder through if I'm going to get an experience I never had before." And this is why I've been sticking with it; I think Keith is on the right lines with this quotation.
games
innovation
criticism
writing
keithstuart
review
mirrorsedge
november 2008 by infovore
Copy this bookmark: