Vaguery + argument   5

Why I’m So Mean -- Daily Intel
"Most people don’t follow these issues for a living and have a hard time distinguishing legitimate arguments from garbage. I don’t mean this patronizingly: I certainly would have trouble distinguishing valid arguments from nonsense in a technical field I didn’t study professionally. But that's why there’s a value in signaling that some arguments aren’t merely expressing a difference in values or interpretation, but are made by an unqualified hack peddling demonstrable nonsense. Being so mean is a labor of love, I confess, but also one with a purpose."
via:cshalizi  politics  argument  reality-based  not-all-differences-of-opinion-are-just-that 
february 2012 by Vaguery
Civility and Incivility, Truth and Fiction at #scio10
"Each of the presenters gave a nice, thoughtful, 5-minute talk about their views on the issue, but what everyone was waiting for was the fireworks when open discussion began. For a while the discussion was tame enough, with everyone exchanging platitudes about how they view the issues. But then things got a LOT more heated...."
social-norms  science  academic-culture  online  ironism-FAIL  discourse  argument  personal-brand  disintermediation-in-action 
january 2010 by Vaguery
Participatory Deliberation - HomePage
"I have for all my mature life been impressed by people's tenacity, and in no specific more than discussion, whether in electronic forums or newspapers' letters to the editor..."
via:vielmetti  philosophy  argument  quotes  learning  dialog  modeling  abstraction  insight 
february 2008 by Vaguery
open...: Open Source Unoriginal? - How Unoriginal
"...what most sensible people would regard as a virus is cited as one of 'the more sophisticated examples of code'"
openness  open-source  argument  amusing  complaint  rhetoric  debate-prep 
january 2008 by Vaguery

Copy this bookmark:



description:


tags: